Credit: (Chantal Santoyo for Create CA)

Why this matters

In 2022, California voters overwhelmingly passed Proposition 28 to set aside roughly $1 billion a year to expand K-12 arts education. Students should have access to four core art disciplines — visual arts, music, dance and theater — but not every school in the state offers these forms.

Four years ago, California voters passed Proposition 28 to set aside roughly $1 billion a year to expand K-12 arts and music education in public and charter schools based on their overall enrollment and their students’ family income. Two months ago, California lawmakers passed Assembly Bill 2440 to fine-tune Prop. 28 because districts were sitting on their money, fearing they wouldn’t follow a vague law well.

But parents, teachers and advocates say issues remain. Some call Prop. 28 wasteful taxpayer spending without a vision or complain it’s insufficient to provide education in all art forms. Others stress parents need to monitor how much money their schools get and how it’s spent.

Christine Timmons, a dance teacher and the Visual and Performing Arts chair at a Sweetwater Union district school, said without a vision and plan, Prop. 28 can be wasteful spending of taxpayer dollars. Some schools may be using the funding appropriately, she said, but there should be more coordination and direction for how schools should expand their program to offer all art forms and ensure continuity from elementary through high school.

“This is not frivolous spending,” Timmons said. “It needs to be intentional.”

Award-winning, community-centered investigative news costs resources, time and money. Help us continue this vital work.

The new law is an improvement. It spells out how schools can use state funding, empowers them to pool resources and requires them to publicly post their plans to spend their portion of Prop. 28 funding. 

Statewide, the proposition devotes 1% of California’s K–12 education funding each year for arts and music.

The law clarifies that under Prop. 28’s “supplement, not supplant” rule, the funding must be used for new arts instruction in five eligible disciplines — media arts, visual arts, music, dance and theater.

Districts that used COVID-19 pandemic relief funds to hire arts and music teachers should now also be able to hire those teachers with Prop. 28 funds, said Veronica Alvarez, executive director of Create CA, a Pasadena-based coalition that provides policy expertise and advocacy on arts education. 

If a teacher was hired with one-time money or private dollars that the school no longer receives, Assembly Bill 2440 clarifies that districts can use Prop. 28 funding for that position, she said.

Schools can also pool funds to hire teachers now. If one pays for 20% of a teacher’s salary, for example, and another pays the rest, the teacher’s time would be divided between the schools accordingly.

The updated law will also require public access to school site spending plans starting in January.

This all comes after school leaders flagged major issues with Prop. 28 funding, from a lack of state-level guidance and confusing spending rules to a shortage of arts educators. The confusion led to allegations of misused funds in some districts and unspent millions of dollars in others.

In 2025, former Los Angeles Unified School District superintendent and Prop. 28 author Austin Beutner sued the district, accusing it of diverting millions from the fund to pay for existing salaries. The case is pending in court. 

Last year, inewsource reported Chula Vista Elementary board members cut dozens of positions, including arts and music teachers, while sitting on millions of Prop. 28 dollars. 

Schools had three years to spend all their 2023-24 — or first — allocation of Prop. 28 funds, and an analysis by the news outlet EdSource found that about 85% of schools did so. Those that missed this year’s June 30 deadline to spend Prop. 28 funds will have unspent dollars subtracted from their next allocation. 

While Prop. 28 dollars have helped develop arts programs around the state, the nonprofit agency WestEd reported that media arts, dance and theater remain less common than music and visual arts.

Under state law, students are supposed to have access to four core art disciplines: dance, music, theater and visual arts. Only about 11% of California schools were providing that before Prop. 28, Alvarez said. But the new funding isn’t enough for schools to educate students in all art forms, she said. 

She encourages California families to review how much funding their school gets and where it’s spent. 

She said other states are looking to create a similar fund for arts education now. 

Theoretically, Alvarez said, a robust program should include music, visual arts, dance, and theater for kindergarten through 12th-grade students. No set requirement dictates how often or how long students access these arts except that in high school, students are required to take one yearlong course or two semesters of visual and performing arts  to fulfill California’s so-called A through G requirements to attend college. 

“There’s still a lot of work to be done,” Alvarez said. 

Type of Content

Explainer: Provides context or background, definition and detail on a specific topic.

News: Based on facts, either observed and verified directly by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources.

Andrea Figueroa Briseño is an investigative reporter at inewsource and a corps member for Report For America, a national service program that tasks journalists to report on undercovered communities and issues. She covers education and focuses her reporting on Latino students and families who are part...