Escondido City Council member Joe Garcia is shown in images used in his 2022 and 2026 reelection campaigns. A special counsel told him to stop using the photo in his election material in 2022. (Jennifer Bowman/inewsource)

Why this matters

The councilmember who was up for reelection violated the same law four years ago.

Escondido City Council member Joe Garcia has once again been told he violated the law by using pictures of himself in a police uniform as part of his reelection campaign.

On Wednesday, the same special counsels made a similar ruling, but noted that any violation ended after Election Day. Garcia lost his reelection bid earlier this month to challenger Anthony DiMartino.

Keep up with how local officials navigate the law. Your support funds inewsource’s reporting and keeps City Hall transparent.

A photo of a mailer for Escondido Council member Joe Garcia’s 2026 reelection.

Garcia, a church pastor and former volunteer chaplain with the Escondido Police Department, has served on the Escondido City Council since 2020. In his 2022 reelection campaign, which occurred two years later because of redistricting, he was investigated by a special counsel and told to stop distributing photos of himself in a police chaplain uniform in campaign material “to avoid continuing to violate” state law.

The law at issue is California state Government Code section 3206, which states, “No officer or employee of a local agency shall participate in political activities of any kind while in uniform.”

Garcia did not respond to a request for comment Thursday before publication.

He used the same photo in his 2026 reelection campaign, but blurred the badge in his mailer and put a disclaimer under it on his website. Last month, he told inewsource he thought that would be enough to make him comply with the law.

In a 37-page report released Wednesday, Devany, Pate, Morris & Cameron LLP said that even after blurring the badge, appearing in uniform is a “political activity within the prohibition.”

“Merely blurring the image instead of cropping out the badge and patch or using a different picture entirely coupled with the unblurred picture on the campaign website suggests an intent to retain an association” with the police department, the report said.

The special counsel said that the matter was referred for investigation a week before the election but that the report could not be completed until afterward. The report includes pages of multiple residents notifying the city about the use of the photo.

“To the extent these uses constitute a violation of section 3206, that likely ended
when the polls closed on November 3,” the report said.

Garcia did not respond to investigators, the report said.

In 2022, he told the special counsel he had no intent to deceive anyone or to violate any laws, rules, or policies; that he was not aware of any prohibition against campaigning in uniform, and that he would comply with the results of the lawyers’ review.

Neither the city nor Garcia have answered questions from inewsource about Garcia’s compliance in 2022.

Katie Futterman is a California Local News fellow who joined inewsource in September 2025 as a community reporter covering San Diego’s North County. She fell in love with journalism when she discovered the power of the human voice in telling stories that can otherwise feel abstract and complex. In...